top of page
  • Writer's pictureTaylor-Ann Bergeron

The Fire Insurance Exodus

In recent years, California has experienced a significant increase in devastating wildfires, wreaking havoc on communities, infrastructure, and the environment. These catastrophic events have placed an enormous financial burden on insurance companies, leading to a concerning trend of insurers withdrawing from the California market altogether. State Farm, Allstate and now Farmers have all stopped giving new coverage to homeowners. The phenomenon of insurance companies leaving California over fire insurance is a complex issue that warrants careful examination. In this blog post, we will delve into the reasons behind this exodus and explore potential implications for Californians.

California's diverse geography, coupled with its dry and hot climate, creates the perfect conditions for wildfires. Over the past decade, the state has witnessed an alarming rise in the frequency and severity of wildfires, resulting in unprecedented property damage and significant insurance claims. Insurers are compelled to assess the risks associated with providing coverage in fire-prone areas and adjust their rates accordingly. However, as wildfires become more frequent and destructive, insurance companies face mounting losses, prompting them to reevaluate their involvement in the California market.

Wildfires, especially those of colossal magnitude, have inflicted substantial financial losses upon insurance companies. The massive payouts to policyholders for property damage, business interruption, and personal belongings, coupled with the escalating costs of rebuilding and restoration, strain the financial resources of insurers. As a result, some companies have found it economically unsustainable to continue offering fire insurance in California, leading to their withdrawal from the market or imposing higher premiums and stricter underwriting criteria.

Back in 1988 proposition 103 was passed in the state of California that allowed the insurance commissioner to raise or decrease rates at a slower pace and as he saw fit. And that is why rates have not risen very much over time. Law makers want to see rates rise at a normal pace . And the hope is that, paired with efforts to increase fire safety - doing things like intentional burns or clearing brush - may ultimately sort of rebalance the insurance market.

Reinsurance plays a crucial role in mitigating the financial risks faced by insurance companies. It allows insurers to transfer a portion of their risks to other entities, thereby providing them with a measure of financial stability. However, the increasing severity of wildfires has made it challenging for insurers to find affordable and comprehensive reinsurance coverage. As reinsurance costs soar, insurance companies are left with limited options to manage their exposure to wildfire risks effectively, leading to higher premiums for policyholders or outright withdrawal from the market.

The departure of insurance companies from California's fire insurance market can have far-reaching consequences for residents and businesses. The reduced availability of coverage may force homeowners, particularly those in high-risk areas, to seek coverage from specialized or surplus lines insurers, which often offer policies at higher rates. Additionally, the lack of competition resulting from insurance companies' departure could lead to a monopolistic market, further driving up premiums and limiting coverage options. The burden of securing affordable and comprehensive fire insurance could disproportionately affect vulnerable communities and exacerbate socio-economic disparities.

The exodus of insurance companies from California's fire insurance market is a complex issue driven by escalating wildfire risks, mounting financial losses, regulatory challenges, and limited reinsurance options. While the long-term implications of this trend are yet to unfold fully, it is essential for policymakers, regulators, and stakeholders to collaboratively explore solutions that balance the need for consumer protection with the financial viability of insurers. Strengthening fire prevention and mitigation efforts, fostering innovative risk management strategies, and encouraging public-private partnerships are crucial steps towards building resilience and ensuring the availability of affordable fire insurance in California for the long term.


bottom of page